thatcoinguy's Blog

31 May 2022

PCGS Rattlers

Exonumia | thatcoinguy

As our hobby grows more and more diverse, collecting interests have gotten broader and broader (which is not necessarily a bad thing!). Collecting interests have grown put to feature old Whitman blue folders, numismatic literature, thelowestgrade coins (a subject of a future blog!)... the list goes on and on. One section that has seen particular activity has been the collecting of slabs. Yes, some people collect slabs. Here's one of the coolest kinds of slabs (in my opinion), and one of the most highly collected.

After ANACS first started, there was a HUGE uptake in demand for this new "grading service". In 1986, PCGS was the next TPG to show up on the market (see my blog from a while ago on the history of the leading TPG). Fun fact: The first coin PCGS ever graded was a 1934 Light Motto Silver Washing Quarter, graded on February 8th, 1986. PCGS were the ones that invented the revolutionary, tamper-proof slabs, and their first model is now nicknamed the "rattler".

Rattlers were made from 1986-1989. Rattlers are called rattlers because the holders were not the exact size of the coin, so you would hear a little rattle if you moved the slab up and down. There were three different versions of rattlers: Gens 1.0, 1.1, and 1.2. Gen 1.0 is the rarest of all PCGS slabs. It was only used for the first few days of production, before Gen 1.1 came along. Gen 1.1 was used for a little longer, but still only used for a week. Both had white paper with the grades on it. Gen 1.2 was the first slab to use green paper, and was used for the rest of 1986, 1987, and all the way until October 1989, before Gen 2.0 came out, and the rattle problem was fixed. This holder is common, but is growing scarcer overtime.

The pictures are in order: Gen 1.0, Gen 1.1, and then Gen 1.2.

Keep collecting,

Pictures are curtesy of PCGS.


Kevin Leab

Level 4

Great blog! I have a few rattlers as well which will rarely see daylight

Long Beard

Level 5

The biggest reason these command a higher premium is availability. More and more are being resubmitted in the hopes of a higher grade. I own several, which will not be submitted for that reason, bought before they became collectible.


Level 7

I like the old rattlers.. I don't know how much they go for. I'm an old timer. I like some of the lower grade coins. I think of who had them years ago. Then I wonder why they had them slabbed. I have F15 good. Genuine. They tell a story. Especially the year. . As usual good blog . Thanks !.


Level 6

Great blog! I have some of those "Old Holders", and yes, they indeed "rattle"! ; )


Level 4

This is an interesting history of "slabs." I guess as coins go, everything at some point is "collectible." Appreciate the history and information. That dot-matrix printed labels make me chuckle, along with the term "rattlers."


Level 4

Nice blog! Thanks!


Level 6

Nice blog. yeah a lot of people are collecting slabs now. I have a couple of coins in rattlers. They do indeed rattle. They also have a nasty habit of turning in the slab. PCGS has a very cool display of their slab history. Thanks

It's Mokie

Level 6

You have some nice coins there.

AC coin$

Level 6

Beautifull colns collection .

We use cookies to provide users the best experience on our website. If you continue without changing your cookie settings, we'll assume that you agree to receive all cookies on money.org. You may disable cookies at any time using your internet browser configuration. By continuing to use this website, you agree to our privacy policy and terms of use. To learn more about how we use cookies and to review our privacy policy, click here.